Pillar 05: Retention
Flows send about one in twenty messages and earn roughly two in five email dollars and close to half of SMS dollars.
That's from Klaviyo's 2026 benchmarks, and it changes what the week after Cyber Monday is for. Black Friday hands you a pile of first orders. The second order, and for subscribers the third, is where a consumer brand starts making money.
So the most useful build this month isn't another promo. It's the post-purchase branch and the renewal reminder that run while you're busy shipping.
What changed
TCPA
Nov 25, still
The revised opt-out rules start the day before Thanksgiving. The relief is for informational texts like shipping updates. A STOP on a promo text still ends every promo text, so the shipping texts that sneak in a discount code are the ones to clean up.
Brownstein client alert (opens in a new tab)Oct 27, 2026Reported
Klaviyo
Tracking consent
Klaviyo added a preference page block that lets recipients switch off open and click tracking, shown only in regions you pick. Opens were already unreliable. Where this is on, clicks get thinner too, and Shopify orders become the number to trust.
Klaviyo What's New (opens in a new tab)Nov 3, 2026Confirmed
Shopify
Store credit you can see
Customer accounts now show the store credit balance in the header, and self-serve returns can be set per market. Credit people can see gets spent. That makes store credit a cheaper second-order nudge than another percent off.
Shopify changelog, via Releasebot (opens in a new tab)Nov 10 and Nov 12, 2026Confirmed
The numbers
SMS click rate, flows against campaigns
Share of SMS recipients who clicked, all ecommerce.
- Flows
- Campaigns
Source: Klaviyo 2026 SMS Benchmarks, updated Sep 24, 2026 (opens in a new tab)Sep 24, 2026Confirmed
See the data as a table
| Segment | Flows | Campaigns |
|---|---|---|
| Average | 9.65% | 5.6% |
| Top 10% | 16.6% | 10.44% |
Email placed order rate, flows against campaigns
Share of email recipients who bought.
- Flows
- Campaigns
Source: Klaviyo 2026 Email Benchmarks, updated Sep 24, 2026 (opens in a new tab)Sep 24, 2026Confirmed
See the data as a table
| Industry | Flows | Campaigns |
|---|---|---|
| Health and beauty | 1.65% | 1.02% |
| Food and beverage | 1.79% | 1.16% |
| Home and garden | 2.17% | 1.34% |
Benchmarks
Each figure with its source and the date or window it covers. A range means the sources disagree or the figure is a band.
| Metric | Figure | Source | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Email flow share of email revenue | 41% | Klaviyo 2026 Email Benchmarks (opens in a new tab)Updated Sep 24, 2026Confirmed | Nearly 41% of email revenue from 5.3% of email sends |
| SMS flow share of SMS revenue | 45.2% | Klaviyo 2026 SMS Benchmarks (opens in a new tab)Updated Sep 24, 2026Confirmed | From 7.6% of SMS sends |
| Email click rate, flows | 5.58% | Klaviyo 2026 Email Benchmarks (opens in a new tab)Updated Sep 24, 2026Confirmed | Against 1.69% for campaigns |
| Email click rate, campaigns | 1.69% | Klaviyo 2026 Email Benchmarks (opens in a new tab)Updated Sep 24, 2026Confirmed | Top 10% of campaigns reach 3.38% |
| SMS click rate, flows | 9.65% | Klaviyo 2026 SMS Benchmarks (opens in a new tab)Updated Sep 24, 2026Confirmed | Top 10% reach 16.6% |
| SMS click rate, campaigns | 5.6% | Klaviyo 2026 SMS Benchmarks (opens in a new tab)Updated Sep 24, 2026Confirmed | Top 10% reach 10.44% |
| SMS order rate, flows | 1.9% | Klaviyo 2026 SMS Benchmarks (opens in a new tab)Updated Sep 24, 2026Confirmed | Against 0.27% for SMS campaigns |
| Open rate, all ecommerce, flows | 32.2% | Klaviyo 2026 Email Benchmarks (opens in a new tab)Updated Sep 24, 2026Confirmed | Inflated by Apple Mail Privacy Protection. Not a primary KPI |
| Metric | Figure | Source | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Open rate, all ecommerce, campaigns | 31% | Klaviyo 2026 Email Benchmarks (opens in a new tab)Updated Sep 24, 2026Confirmed | Same Apple MPP caveat |
Unsubscribe rate, list growth rate, repeat purchase rate, time to second order and loyalty participation still have no Tier 1 or independent source, so they stay blank rather than filled with vendor round numbers. Subscription churn by renewal is on the watch list until a second source backs it.
Every change
2 changes logged this week, highest impact first.
| Change | Impact | Source | When |
|---|---|---|---|
| Benchmarks filled: SMS click and order rates, and flow share of email and SMS revenue | High | Klaviyo 2026 Email and SMS Benchmarks (opens in a new tab)Sep 24, 2026Confirmed | Added Nov 16, 2026 |
| Judge on placed orders read from Shopify where tracking consent limits clicks; opens are not a KPI | Medium | Klaviyo What's New (opens in a new tab)Nov 3, 2026Confirmed | Nov 16, 2026 |
Standing rules
How we read Email and SMS now, newest first. See the full log across every issue.
| Rule | Area | Change | Logged | Supersedes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Judge email and SMS on placed orders and revenue per recipient, read from Shopify where tracking is limited. Clicks are secondary. Opens are not a KPI. | Measurement | refines | Judge on clicks, placed order rate and revenue per recipient, not opens. | |
| Say “Reply STOP to opt out” in every marketing text and honor all seven keywords within 10 business days. Keep honoring free-text opt-outs. | SMS opt-out | refines | Honor STOP and common keywords. Updated for FCC 26-67. | |
| Category-specific opt-outs apply only to informational texts. Keep codes and product links out of order, shipping and delivery texts, or treat them as marketing. | Transactional SMS | new | The 2024 revoke-all rule for informational messages. | |
| Build welcome, browse, cart and checkout abandonment, post-purchase, replenishment, win-back and sunset flows before scaling campaigns. | Core flows | new | Nothing | |
| Segment offers by discount history. Do not give the deepest discount to people who buy at full price. | Offers | new | Nothing | |
| Keep Gmail spam complaints under 0.1% and never at 0.3%. Authenticate with SPF, DKIM and DMARC on a branded domain. | Deliverability | new | Nothing | |
| Judge loyalty, subscriptions and post-purchase on contribution margin per customer against a comparison group, not on attributed revenue. | Retention programs | new | Nothing | |
| Read churn by renewal cycle, put reminders and skip and swap before renewals two and three, and keep cancel as easy as signup. | Subscriptions | new | Nothing |
Retired claims
Figures and claims we stopped repeating, and why.
No claims retired this week.
What to watch next week
- TCPA, week oneWhether the FCC clarifies anything after Nov 25, and whether the first lawsuits cite the new rules.
- Klaviyo Compliance HubStill marked coming soon. What the SMS compliance score actually measures.
- Black Friday numbersAdobe, Shopify and Klaviyo results for Nov 27 to 30, and how much came through email and SMS.
- Subscription churn timingRecharge's own data says about 61% of voluntary cancels land at the first two renewals. Unverified until a second source backs it.
- Shopify Editions Fall 2026An agency summary says Shopify Messaging can send WhatsApp abandonment messages. Unverified until checked against Shopify.
Terms used
- Flow
- An automated series triggered by behavior, such as an abandoned cart or a first purchase, as opposed to a campaign sent to a list on a date.
- Renewal cycle
- Each recurring subscription order after the first. The first renewal is the second order.
- Voluntary and involuntary churn
- Voluntary churn is a customer canceling. Involuntary churn is a failed card. They need different fixes.
- Store credit
- A balance a customer can spend at the store, issued as a reward, a refund or a goodwill gesture.
Where we read it
The outlets we watch for this channel. A figure's status follows its best source.
- Klaviyo product updates (opens in a new tab)Tier 1, the platform itself
